问HN：Reddit现在对新用户来说是一个敌对的地方吗？
我最近建立了一个开源的Nix项目，想与r/NixOS的朋友们分享。<p>我在2023年注册了一个账号，但我并不常用这个账号，而且之前选择的用户名也不太喜欢，所以我创建了一个新账号，并将项目发布到r/NixOS，但我的帖子立即被删除，账号也被阴影禁言。我又创建了几个账号，结果在发布后都被阴影禁言。<p>后来我了解到，大多数子版块要求用户在被认为可信之前必须拥有一定的声望，这可以理解，但不显示声望要求而直接删除帖子并进行阴影禁言的做法实在太敌对了。<p>我尝试用新账号申诉，过了两个月也没有回应，禁言依然没有解除。<p>后来我开始重新使用我的2023年账号，这次我注意到了声望。我主要只是评论，并在一些对声望要求不高的子版块发了一两条帖子。有一条帖子获得了很多点赞和回复，给我带来了24点帖子声望，我认为这足以证明我不是个垃圾信息发布者。因此，我在r/macapps上发布了一条帖子，发布了我最近开发的Mac应用。帖子也立即被删除，但我的账号没有被阴影禁言。后来，我惊讶地发现帖子被恢复了，并开始收到其他Reddit用户的回复。一位Reddit用户私信我说她是一名学生，觉得我的应用很有用，问我是否有折扣码。我回复说她是第一个问我这个的人，我就给她一个免费版。但是就在我发送兑换码后，我的账号又一次被阴影禁言了。我最后发的消息，表示如果她能留下评价我会很感激，却无法发送给她。<p>那一刻对我来说真是太糟糕了。<p>我昨天立即尝试申诉，今天却发现我甚至无法登录账号，提示我的用户名和密码无效。重置密码也没有用。<p>现在Reddit对新用户来说是个活地狱吗？我想知道其他人是否也有类似的经历？
查看原文
I recently build an open source nix project and I want to share it with people in r/NixOS.<p>I have an account I made in 2023, but I don't really use it and I don't really like the user name I previously picked, so I made a new account and posted the project to r/NixOS, but my post was immediately removed and my account shadow banned. I created a bunch more accounts and they were all shadow banned after posting.<p>I later learned that most subreddits require you to have a certain karma before they consider you trustworthy, which makes sense, but the practice of not showing the karma requirement and simply deleting the post with shadow banning is just so hostile.<p>I tried appealing with the new account, 2 months after, no response and the ban is still not lifted.<p>I later started to reuse my 2023 account, and this time paid attention to the karma. I mostly just commented and made one or two posts to subreddits that don't require a high karma. One post got a lot of upvotes and replies, and gave me 24 post karma, I thought that was enough to prove I'm not a spammer. So I made a post in r/macapps, releasing a Mac app I recently built. It immediately got removed too, but didn't get my account shadow banned. Later, I was surprised to find out the post was restored, and I started to get replies from redditors. One redditor messaged me saying she is a student and has found my app useful and asked if I have a discount code. I replied since she is the first one who asked I will just give her a free copy. But right after I sent the redeem code, my account was shadow banned again. My final message saying I'd appreciate it if she could leave a review couldn't be sent to her.<p>It was such a terrible moment for me.<p>I tried appealing immediately yesterday, and today I found out I can't even log in the account, saying my username and password are invalid. Resetting password doesn't work.<p>Is reddit a living hell for new users now? I wonder if others share the experience?