问HN：如果反对投票需要理由，HN会变得更好吗？
长时间潜水，我一直很享受这里的技术讨论，但最近我觉得有必要多评论几句。<p>通常，这里的体验是积极的，但有时讨论似乎停滞不前，我对一些评论有几点看法，然后过几个小时或一天再回来，发现我的评论被投了负分，却没有任何新的回复。<p>1）这感觉不像是自然流量。正常的投票（无论是赞成还是反对）是稳定的，而反对票则是集中出现，有时甚至在一两个小时后就出现。<p>2）我觉得这使得讨论贬值为一种受欢迎程度的竞争。如果你不同意我的观点，那也没关系，但你应该能够清晰地表达你的不同意见。如果人们只是不同意，并觉得有必要让我知道，他们应该在脑中充分处理我所写的内容，以形成一个连贯的理由。
查看原文
Long time lurker, I always enjoyed the technical discussions here but lately I feel the need to comment more.<p>Usually, the experience is positive but there are instances where the discussion seems to settle, I have a few points on some comments, then come back a few hours or a day later and my comments are downvoted into negative numbers without any new replies.<p>1) This doesn't feel like organic traffic. Normal votes (both up and down) come in steadily, the downvotes come in all at once, sometimes they appear even after just an hour or two.<p>2) I feel like they devalue discussions into a popularity contest. If you disagree with me, that's fine but you should be able to articulate the disagreement. If people just disagree and feel the need to let me know, they should have to process what I wrote in their brain sufficiently to form a coherent reason.